Managerial discourse as the rationale of the organization's control

Resumo

This article handles with the use of the instrumental reason by the speakers of the political power in the organization through the discourse. The discourse as a expression of the instrumental reason presents an objective, to demonstrate to the actors, in the form of a false consciousness, values that in a first moment are not those believed by the actors as individuals. These values, that in a lower level mean to obey, to respect, handle with the actor's submission to the organization objective. In a second  moment the so-called actor's personal objectives will be substituted by the organization objectives. We may call this false consciousness, or falsifiable knowing. That is, the discourse assumes that the actors can be manipulated to agree that the declarations expressed by the discourse, and also their position, are correct. This is the first step to conduct the actor to a conformist position. Opposed  to this position we handle with the concept of discursive (or communicative) reason according  to Habermas. This is a position that offers us a distinct viewpoint, because actor's and  speaker’s discourse can be discussed in an argumentation and counter-argumentation basis. Organization al also can be seen in a distinct view: from a structure of distorted communications view to a structure of communicative interaction view, a setting where speakers and actors have the possibility of communicative interaction. This view legitimates, or validates, their position, intentions, and also the setting and  its norms. In this sense, according to Habermas (and also according to Forester) the communicative reason conducts to the veracity of what is proposed by speakers and actors, the authenticity of their position, and the justice of the proposed norms and rules, and in so doing, the communicative reason  is interested in its use by the social speakers and  actors.

Ficha do documento

Tipo

Artigo científico

Ano

1991

Instituição

Escola Brasileira de Administração Pública e de Empresas da Fundação Getulio Vargas (FGV EBAPE)

Fonte

Revista de Administração Pública

Idioma

Português

Acesso

Não informado

Identificador

oai:ojs.periodicos.fgv.br:article/8970

Palavras-chave

Critical consciousnessmanagerial discoursefalse consciousnesspolitical unconsciouspolitical powercommunicative reason (or discursive)instrumental reason.La conciencia críticadiscurso gerencialfalsa concienciapolítica inconscienteel poder políticorazón comunicativa (o discursiva)la razón instrumental.Consciência criticafalsa consciênciainconsciente políticopoder políticorazão comunicativa (ou discursiva)razão instrumental.